Skip to content
Migration

Eleventh Circuit rules that an I-220A does not establish parole for Cuban adjustment

The binding ruling in three states distinguishes supervised release from the immigration benefit required to apply for permanent residence.

2 min read

Editorial illustration depicting the Eleventh Circuit ruling that an I-220A does not establish parole for Cuban adjustment
Illustration: Malecón90

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit ruled that a person's release on Form I-220A does not, by itself, show that the person was granted parole. The decision affects people seeking to use that document to satisfy a requirement of the Cuban Adjustment Act and apply for permanent residence. Because it is a published opinion, the ruling is binding on federal courts in Florida, Georgia and Alabama with respect to the issues it addresses.

The decision arose from an appeal by Yoan Aguiar-Fernández, his wife, Yenisley González-Sanabria, and their daughter. The family arrived in the United States through the Mexican border in June 2021 and was detained by the Border Patrol; they were later released on I-220A forms. When they applied for Cuban adjustment, their petitions were denied because they had not satisfied the requirement of having been admitted or paroled into the country.

The judges distinguished release under Section 1226 of the Immigration and Nationality Act from humanitarian parole under Section 212(d)(5)(A). According to the ruling, an I-220A documents release from custody subject to conditions but does not prove that the Department of Homeland Security granted parole. In the family's record, the forms cited Section 1226 as the basis for the measure.

The family argued that immigration authorities should have applied a different legal provision and that their release should be treated as parole. The court rejected that interpretation and focused its analysis on the basis recorded by the agency and what it actually granted. The ruling also says a release cannot be converted into parole solely because someone claims a different legal avenue should have been used. Based on the family's record, the decision also upheld the denials of their applications for asylum and other protections.

The ruling could influence the class-action lawsuit Bello-Rubio v. Noem, filed in Miami by 992 immigrants with I-220A forms. The lawsuit seeks recognition of the circumstances of their detention and subsequent release as parole so they can apply for residence under the Cuban law. The new precedent may complicate that argument, but it does not automatically dismiss the lawsuit: Judge Jacqueline Becerra must evaluate its effect on the pending case.

The decision does not eliminate the Cuban Adjustment Act or establish that everyone with an I-220A must be deported. Nor does it prevent a person from satisfying the requirement through another avenue and proving a valid admission or grant of parole. Its specific reach is narrower: the form alone is not enough to prove the required immigration benefit. The judge must decide the class-action litigation in light of the precedent and the parties' arguments.

Sources consulted

12 outlets
KEEP READING
Migration

Cuban doctor remains detained in Texas as family awaits immigration ruling

Miguel Ángel Alba Rosario has been in ICE custody for more than a year; his attorneys seek to prevent a possible deportation while his wife raises their three children alone.

Migration

Cuban deported to Central African Republic says he has no documents or work permit

Eric González Peña remains in Bangui, separated from his wife and three-year-old son; his family questions the removal and says a court appeal was pending.

Migration

Ninth Circuit Opens Way to Reinstate Venezuelan TPS

The protection could come back into effect on November 6, after an appeals panel refused to keep it suspended; the Supreme Court can still intervene.